Civilian casualty count mechanic need to be fixed in aoh3

[angamo123 141]

Dear @Łukasz Jakowski in aoh2 civilian casualty count mechanic is very bad, when a battle happend in a occupied province, the civilian casualty will be counted to who is occupying that province instead of owner of that province. Exp usa and mexico have war between them and mexico occupied California then usa attack California to retake, all civilian casualty in that retake battle will be counted to mexico instead of the usa the owner of that province. Can you fix it in Aoh3?

Edited January 28, 2024 by angamo123

[Łukasz Jakowski 13,363]

There won't be civilian casualties

[Capodastr 814]

22 minutes ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

There won't be civilian casualties

May be they should be :р

Just no logic

[mrx 49]

37 minutes ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

Жертв среди гражданского населения не будет

This is unrealistic

[qxz 622]

5 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

There won't be civilian casualties

Lukasz, as much as I respect your decisions regarding the game, I and many others find this decision difficult to understand.

Age of History as a whole is remembered as game based on conflict and war.

War is the pure representation of destruction and chaos. War has consequences and this should be reflected in the game.

War MUST have negative consequences to both the player's country and the country which the AI is controlling. This should include weight in the form of civilian casualties. A player should think before launching a yet another attack on another country as it can result in their country being nuked/occupied, resulting in civilian loss of life. 

Loss of civilian population has an extremely negative effect on the country's economy as a whole. 

Please Lukasz, include this in the game!

[Minemaster552 23]

2 hours ago, qxz said:

Age of History as a whole is remembered as game based on conflict and war.

I mostly agree with this post, yet I personally think a balance of peaceful and "aggressive" ways to take over land should be reflected in the game.

[Samuel05 21]

13 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

There won't be civilian casualties

There should be civilian casualties tho, what about nuked? That seems unrealistic

[Pistoletoff 13]

22 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

Жертв среди гражданского населения не будет

Don't worry, the modders will do it for you)

[Mr Who Are You 4]

23 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

There won't be civilian casualties

WHY.

[Łukasz Jakowski 13,363]

Once a province is occupied, the province will be devastated, which will reduce the province's income for some time

 

After a nuclear attack, there are civilian casualties

[angamo123 141]

2 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

Once a province is occupied, the province will be devastated, which will reduce the province's income for some time

 

After a nuclear attack, there are civilian casualties

Just income be reduced? Population of the province should be reduced too due to battle

[mysta 85]

6 hours ago, Łukasz Jakowski said:

Once a province is occupied, the province will be devastated, which will reduce the province's income for some time

 

After a nuclear attack, there are civilian casualties

I think there should be a looting system like in age of history 2 and this system should be developed. So that there are types of looting (economic looting, civilian looting, etc.)

[help me please 3]

6 hours ago, angamo123 said:

Just income be reduced? Population of the province should be reduced too due to battle

tbf, population will already be reduced in battle, as im pretty sure you need pops to create units

[angamo123 141]

On 1/28/2024 at 6:08 AM, Łukasz Jakowski said:

There won't be civilian casualties

Dear @Łukasz Jakowski how about this idea. Turn civilian casualties from battle and civilian casualties from nuclear attack into percentage value for terrain types like economy grow and population grow in terrain types editor so we can adjust civilian casualties base on terrain types. Example, we adjust civilian casualties from battle in city terrain is 50% of population and civilian casualties from nuclear attack is 50% population but in hill or forest terrain we ajust the values lower like 10% or 0% of population so when there is a battle happened in province has city terrain 50% of its population will be lost but in hill province 10% or 0% of its population will be lost.